2021 CW Top Shops highlights strengths of top composites facilities
CW learned from some of this year’s designated Top Shops about what makes facilities stand out, from diverse capabilities to Industry 4.0 and sustainability.
This marks year three for CW Top Shops, an annual benchmarking survey launched by CompositesWorld, in cooperation with Gardner Intelligence. The survey itself, which readers and composites facilities were invited to complete earlier this year, asks facilities to submit data in many areas related to their operations, including capacity utilization, on-time delivery, scrap rate and much more.
Participating composites fabricators were provided with a customized report contextualizing their operations with that of others who took the survey, as a way to gain a valuable perspective on how their facility measures up. Participating companies are ranked for each metric, which gives an overall ranking for each facility.
Fig. 1-5 in the slideshow below show several of the metrics we measured, demonstrating how Top Shops compare with other participating facilities in the types of industries served, scrap rate, capacity utilization and more:
Fig. 1-5
Fig. 1 Industries served
Fig. 2 Composites processes
Fig. 3 Shop type
Fig. 4 Capacity utilization
Fig. 5 Scrap rate
What makes a Top Shop?
This year, CW reached out to these 10 Top Shops to learn more about their facilities and to understand, beyond the numbers, what makes them stand out.
From diverse capabilities and a team capable of overcoming obstacles, to a focus on next-generation technologies such as Industry 4.0 and sustainability efforts, what follows are summaries of the answers we received.
B&T Composites
Response from Kosmas Tiriakidis, production manager
Processes: Filament winding, vacuum infusion, wrapping, hand layup
End markets served: Mostlyindustrial and wind; also marine, aerospace, energy storage
B&T Composites’ facility in Florina, Greece.
Photo Credit: B&T Composites
How has your company adjusted to or overcome challenges over the last year? “Our only way to go on was to think out of the box. We quickly modified our production into carbon fiber, high-end products. Our strength is also based on our cooperation with technical universities in Greece. We are lucky to have fruitful cooperation with the fields of mechanical engineering, material engineering, aerospace engineering and, recently, with photonics engineering, introducing a new smart composites series with optical sensors.”
How does your company employ Industry 4.0/data within your operations? “We have installed sensors in all production steps [controlling temperature, viscosity of the resin, fiber tensioning, humidity]. We also use sensors for preventive maintenance of our machines. Moreover, we have developed a tracking system with unique serial numbers for each of our products. With a serial number [QR code], we have all steps of production [raw materials, machines used, procedures, etc.] for perfect traceability for all of our products.”
How does sustainability factor into your facility’s operations? “We use solar energy for a high percentage of our electricity needs, including lighting for our production area and water heating.”
Bucci Composites
Response by Andrea Bedeschi, general manager (see full CW Trending interview with CW Editor-in-Chief Jeff Sloan here)
Location: Faenza, Italy
Date founded: 1988
Number of employees: 250
Materials: Carbon fiber composites
Processes: Hand layup/autoclave, infusion, wet layup, LP-RTM, HP-RTM, compression molding
End markets served: Automotive, motorsports, aerospace, marine, construction, industrial
What were the original goals of the company? “Originally, we started as a Formula 1 supplier particularly for Ferrari in Italy. Our first name was RIBA Composites, but in 2020, we changed the name to Bucci Composites, because last year was the 20th anniversary of the acquisition of RIBA Composites by the industrial group Bucci Industries. In that time, we moved to larger production in automotive and aerospace.”
How has your company adjusted to or overcome challenges over the past year? “The situation in Italy started out pretty badly [due to COVID-19], but now it seems like the situation is getting better, we hope. Business-wise, last year was not so terrible for us, because we were able to continue work on existing projects. A potential risk this year has been that many programs stopped development last year and those effects continue into this year. Starting about March of this year, OEMs are starting again to develop new products.”
What are your thoughts or expectations going into the rest of this year and 2022? “We have a lot of projects under development, especially in automotive. This year will be a transition year, but we expect next year to be a very good year. We’re also investing in new presses, and in 2022-2023, we plan to significantly enlarge the shop floor area to follow the company’s growth.”
Cecence Ltd.
Response from Samantha Bunyan, co-founder and head of industry engagement and sustainability
End markets served: Aerospace, rail, sports and recreation, defense, space
What sets your company apart? “Cecence is a close-knit team who pulls together to find the best solutions for our clients. Mutual respect across all levels of the company is important, and in the same way, as we drive innovation through collaboration with partners and customers, we encourage this internally, enabling members of the team to grow and develop as part of an interdisciplinary approach.”
How has your company adjusted to or overcome industry challenges over the past year? “One of the positives is the ‘pause’ button pressed by the pandemic, offering an opportunity to push through R&D and new development programs. We have used this time to invest in a formulation lab and increased investment in sustainable materials and processing development.” With support from Innovate UK, the Temporary Sustainable Framework program and the KTN Women in Innovation program, new R&D includes development of an UltraSlim sustainable aircraft seatback incorporating recycled carbon fiber and bio-resin, and a sustainable aircraft tray table.
How does sustainability factor into your operations? “Cecence’s ambition is to be the market leader in lightweight, sustainable composite solutions for the mass transportation sector. We have always focused on manufacturing using low energy, rapid processing and increasingly have been able to feed in recycled carbon and natural fiber composites into our product portfolio.”
Champion Fiberglass
Response from Goran Haag, president
Location: Spring, Texas, U.S.
Date founded: 1988
Facility size: 110,000 square feet
Number of employees: 140
Materials: Fiberglass and epoxy
Processes: Filament winding, compression molding and a hybrid process between vacuum infusion and RTM
End markets served: Infrastructure, industrial
What can you share about your facility’s strategy for quality management? “We are one of the few in our industry that are both ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certified and in a few months we will also be ISO 45001 certified [internal safety/OSHA].”
The company specializes in fiberglass conduits and fittings. Photo Credit: Champion Fiberglass
How does your company employ Industry 4.0/data within your operations? “We are moving strongly towards automation in many parts of our manufacturing. We will implement complete robotics in our entire filament winding units within a couple of years.”
How does sustainability factor into your operations? “We are just about to install the first part of a recycling unit that should be operational towards the end of the year. We have also installed a new water purification unit and we are working on reducing our overall water usage and try to recycle more where feasible.”
EPP Composites
Response from Jayraj Shah, managing director
Location: Rajkot, India
Date founded: 1986
Facility size: 850,000 square feet, with 10 plants
Processes: Compression molding, injection molding, vacuum infusion, hand layup, RTM/LRTM/VARTM, multi-axis and continuous filament winding, hoop-chop winding, pultrusion
End markets served: Building/construction, infrastructure, industrial, oil and gas
What was the original goal of your company? “EPP was established in 1986 with the intention to develop its place in the composites market with a focus on corrosion-resistant product solutions for the industry, by introducing new processes and applications to replace conventional, metal-based product applications, and a strong commitment to quality and customer service.”
How has your company adjusted to or overcome challenges over the past year? “Though the past year has posed innumerable challenges, we have kept the continuity of all aspects of manufacturing to support our customers. Challenges have included availability of raw materials, slowdown of receivables and available manpower. These were mitigated to a great extent with calibrated action plans, including EPP’s automated production plan and ERP system that have been in place since 2008.”
How does your company employ Industry 4.0/data within your operations? “EPP’s immediate roadmap to Industry 4.0 is in four areas: smart innovation, smart factory, smart solutions and smart supply chain. Actions underway include upgrades to capital equipment, redesigning workflows to require fewer experienced operators by replacing more information systems, automating the order process, improving product quality and shortening delivery times.”
GSE Dynamics Inc.
Response from Anne D. Shybunko-Moore, owner and CEO
Location: Hauppauge, N.Y., U.S.
Date founded: 1971
Facility size: 30,000-square-foot corporate headquarters/manufacturing facility, and 57,000-square-foot composites/machining facility
Processes: Prepreg/autoclave, vacuum infusion, adhesive bonding, additive manufacturing, multi-axis machining, assembly, non-destructive testing, material qualification and quality conformance testing
End markets served: Defense, aerospace
What was the original goal of your company? “Daniel J. Shybunko founded the company in 1971. He was working as a structural engineer at Grumman Aerospace at the time and received support to open a small manufacturing company on Long Island that could function as a subcontractor for smaller structures. In 1978 he departed Grumman after 25 years of service and put all of his efforts into expanding GSE’s capability. GSE has demonstrated steady growth for more than 50 years with a broad range of experience on numerous complex structures that support our military operations.”
What are your thoughts or expectations going into the rest of this year/2022? “There continue to be concerns on the effects of COVID-19 in our industry, and currently our biggest concern is the procurement of raw material in terms of lead time and increasing costs. Our industry is also faced with workforce challenges as we look to train the next generation in manufacturing and technology. I am optimistic on all fronts — our industry is very driven to meet the needs of our customers and we will do what needs to be done.”
How does sustainability factor into your operations? “Within our manufacturing process, we are reducing our electrical consumption, improving power quality/factor/voltage, increasing our electrical system capacity, reducing unnecessary heat, improving the cooling capacity of our air conditioning and freezers and installing lighting with extended life, improved light quality and reduced energy consumption. We have also enrolled in a New York State program, Recharge NY, that provides electricity through hydropower to manufacturing companies.”
The Gund Co.
Response from Michael Moran, VP, business development
Location: St. Louis, Mo., U.S.
Date founded: 1951
Facility size: 12 manufacturing locations in five countries
End markets served: Electrical, aerospace, medical, transportation, oil/gas
Gund Co.’s on-site CNC machining center.
Photo Credit: Gund Co.
What was the original goal of your company? “The Gund Company is a third-generation family business established in 1951 by Ed Gund. The business started as a manufacturer’s representative organization for electrical insulation composite materials. Some 25 years later, with son Paul Gund on board, The Gund Company began to distribute and fabricate composite materials. Rich and Steve Gund joined in the 1990s and continued to focus on expanding fabrication and manufacturing capabilities. Since then, the company has grown into one of the largest manufacturers and fabricators of composite, thermoplastic and elastomeric materials.”
What sets your company apart? “We offer more than 300 standard products, but enjoy the opportunity to work closely with engineers to design new products for specific applications. Engineers appreciate the rapid prototyping and testing that we can provide to help speed up their projects. The Gund Company has extensive composite testing capability and development engineering resources available to assist customers with new projects. The Gund Company has always taken an application engineering approach to the business. We want to understand the application, so we can provide solutions for our customers.”
Materials: UD continuous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic tape; glass or carbon fiber; PP, PET, PEEK, PEKK, LM-PAEK, PA6, PA6/6, PA12, PPS
Processes: All processes are developed in-house, including automated tape layup, blank consolidation, forming (hybrid process between thermoforming and stamp forming), CNC trimming/waterjet, light assembly
End markets served: Aerospace, industrial, medical, personal protective equipment (PPE), sporting goods, transportation, unmanned mobility, renewable energy, oil and gas
What sets your company apart? “Unlike many in the composites industry who started with thermosets and then migrated to thermoplastics, we’ve focused only on thermoplastics over these last 13 years. Our founder, Jack Wilfley, developed automation and robotics for the production of continuous fiber thermoplastic structures and components. This combination provides very fast cycle times for composite component production and this is what really sets Oribi apart. We approach every project with what we call a rate-target approach. Often there is a chasm where clients want to transition to composites, yet they require very high volumes along with price points that historically push composites out of reach. Oribi helps clients transition to composites through creative engineering and high-volume manufacturing within a cost structure that makes U.S. manufacturing competitive once again. Oribi has continued to build on this premise over the last 13 years.”
How has your company adjusted to or overcome challenges over the past year? “We’re feeling optimistic. The last year has been a challenge for most everyone; fortunately, we rely on automation and robotics so heavily, the impact on production was minimal in comparison to other industries. That said, we have fantastic employees that stuck with us through the challenging situations and have enabled Oribi to support our customers and keep things moving. Especially when we support critical customers within the energy, military and law enforcement sectors, there are no acceptable supply chain gaps — we have to keep product moving.”
What are your thoughts or expectations going into the rest of this year/2022? “As we look forward into 2022 and beyond, we’re looking into a wide variety of markets which can benefit from our processes, materials and U.S. manufacturing footprint. For example, we have developed wheels for the transportation and powersports market and are putting more focus within the UAV/UAM market. This past year has certainly affected major markets like aerospace, but we anticipate growth for the composites industry as a whole through 2022 and beyond.”
Top Shops 2022
Congratulations to all of this year’s Top Shops, and thank you to all who participated. Keep an eye out for the 2022 CW Top Shops survey, which will launch in January. An announcement will be posted on our website and distributed through the CW Today e-newsletter — or, you can send a note to CW Editor-in-Chief Jeff Sloan at jeff@compositesworld.com to be added to the distribution list.
India-based CW Top Shops honoree EPP Composites reflects on a recently successful vertical filament winding application and new pultruded FRP rebar capabilities, as well as future opportunities.
CW Top Shops honoree Cobra International reflects on its growth over 45+ years, as well as current work expanding its automotive and UAV capabilities, increasing energy efficiency and new SMC production lines.
Texas-based Champion Fiberglass, a five-time CW Top Shops honoree, expands its success in the fiberglass composite conduit market into new applications and products, looking toward future automation and sustainability initiatives.
Long Island-based, four-time CW Top Shops honoree GSE Dynamics cites diversification in processes, digitalization, workforce training and more on its successes over 50+ years, and looks ahead to future growth.
CW's second annual Top Shops benchmarking survey helps composites fabricators put their operations into perspective and illuminates top-ranking facilities.
Oribi Composites’ Matt Christensen discusses the origin of the Colorado-based thermoplastic composites fabricator, his role at the company, current products and programs, and the real potential for use of thermoplastic composites in wheels.
Starting on Tuesday, Jan. 23, 2024, CW will begin “gating” its staff-produced premium content, asking all new website users to provide some information about themselves — name, title, employer, email address — before they are provided free access to the content.
We are doing this because the ways CW’s audience finds and accesses our content is changing. Google’s search algorithms, increasingly, make it difficult to connect CW’s content with the people who might make use of it. On top of that, generative AI like ChatGPT is serving up CW content to internet users without attributing that content to CW.
As a result, it has become increasingly important for CW evolve its audience development strategy and learn as much as possible about who is accessing our content, what content they are accessing and how they are accessing it.
With this audience development strategy, we hope to do two things:
First, we will be better able to deliver directly to our audience the editorial content that aligns with the composite materials, processes and technologies that interest them.
Second, we will be better able to connect the materials, equipment and services our advertisers supply with the audience that is most interested in them.
CW plays a distinctive role and has earned a place of esteem within the focused and specialized industry it serves. Large developments in the media landscape are forcing us to change the way we communicate with our audience. We are confident that our audience values the role CW plays in their professional lives and will join us in this effort to stay connected to them.
We thank you for your continued interest in and support of CW and welcome any questions you might have about the brand’s new content gating strategy.
Welcome! You’ve unlocked CompositesWorld premium content on this device.