Published 9/13/2016

BMW 7 Series Plant: Dingolfing, Germany

Via four different manufacturing methods, CFRP goes mainstream in automated multi-material BIW and assembly operations at BMW’s busiest plant.

Ginger Gardiner

Senior Technical Editor, CompositesWorld

CFRP goes mainstream at BMW’s highly automated and busiest plant, where the multi-material BIW for the 7 Series comes to life.

Next iteration: i models’ CFRP. Dingolfifing, Germany is BMW’s largest manufacturing site in Europe. It produces more than 350,000 cars per year among 15 different models, including three variations of the new BMW 7 Series (left). At right is the BMW i3 all-electric. Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 1: Carbon Core: Multi-material BIW. The BMW 7 Series body-in-white (BIW) is the first to mate aluminum, CFRP and high-strength steel, a combination BMW calls the Carbon Core. Source: BMW AG

Fig. 2: Hybrid CF/steel B-pillar. Using carbon fiber prepreg reinforcement enabled a thinner, high-strength steel B-pillar, saving 2 kg while providing superior crash performance. Source: BMW AG

Fig. 3: Wet pressed “backbone." Wet pressing is used to make the tunnel, which forms the backbone of the 7 Series Carbon Core BIW. Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 4: Recycled SMC C-pillar. Both the 7 Series C-pillar (shown here) and rear cross member/upper trunk cover use recycled carbon fiber SMC. Source: BMW AG

Fig. 5a: Automated milling maximizes throughout. Automated CNC mills enable molded parts — tunnel shown here in machining (see also Fig. 5b). Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 5b: Quality assurance — to be loaded/unloaded at the front of the machine while another is being milled at the back, for maximum throughput and efficiency. Source: BMW AG

Fig. 6a: Wet pressing of sills. Wet compression molding of sills begins with robotic application of epoxy resin onto flat NCF stacks (shown here). These are transferred to a mold and pressed (see Figs 6b & 6c, below). Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 6b: The NCF stacks are transferred to the mold. Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 6c: The molded parts being removed from the mold. Source: BMW AG.

Fig. 7: Tunnel workcell. Robotic arms apply epoxy adhesive to the CFRP tunnel, checking placement, width and continuity via cameras before bonding to metal components. Source: BMW AG

Fig. 8: Subassembly preparation. Multiple CFRP-containing subassemblies are prepared for attachment to the Carbon Core BIW, like this one that contains the RTM roof rail (top), sills and hybrid B-pillar (bottom and center but CF on downward face of both) and SMC reinforcement for C-pillar (far right). Source: BMW AG

Fig. 9: Carbon Core takes shape. Assembly proceeds as the BIW passes through subsequent stations for attachment of side assemblies (shown here). Other subassemblies are robotically lowered into position and fastened or welded until Carbon Core completion. Source: BMW AG

CFRP: 4,000 parts per day

Sixteen CFRP parts make up the Carbon Core, each manufactured using one of four technologies (Fig. 1 and see Table 1 below), with each chosen to meet specific part shape and property requirements, yet minimize weight. Michael Ahlers, BMW head of Process Chain Body-In-White and Exterior, points out the Carbon Core parts on a 7 Series BIW displayed at the entrance to the plant’s 11,000m² CFRP production/logistics area. Noting the B-pillar (Fig. 2), Ahlers explains, “It uses CF prepreg covered with a film of epoxy adhesive. Both are hardened to the formed steel B-pillar in one press step.” High-pressure resin transfer molding (HP-RTM) is used in the roof rail, made in the nearby BMW Landshut plant, to meet roof pressure test requirements, while wet compression molding (or wet pressing, see Learn More) enables cost-effective, short-duration cycle times for parts such as the tunnel, sills and selected roof bows (Fig. 3).

When asked about galvanic corrosion, Ahlers explains that for rear cross member/upper trunk cover (Fig. 4), the only CFRP part in touch with aluminum, adhesive is used to isolate the CFRP from the aluminum. There are no through-hole fasteners to act as a corrosion bridge. Also, the aluminum is painted (black) to prevent corrosion from environmental factors. “The key is to have the right materials and to have them support each other,” says Ahlers.

The cross member/trunk cover is molded from epoxy sheet molding compound (SMC) reinforced with recycled carbon fiber. The fiber is a lofted material, derived from 7 Series waste as well as waste from cutting dry fabrics for BMW’s i3 and i8 moldings. These leavings are carded and formed into nonwoven mat. “In this process, the knowledge is where to put the resin in and how to press it all to avoid dry areas, which happens if you have too much fiber,” says Ahlers. “But, if you have too little fiber, you have too much resin and not enough mechanical properties.”

The recycled carbon fiber SMC parts are not made by BMW, but instead are delivered from a supplier and use epoxy resin. The type of epoxy used, however, is optimized per process. For example, Hexion's (Columbus, OH, US) quick-curing EP TRAC 0600/EK TRAC 06130 epoxy is used in the 7 Series’ HP-RTM roof bows and the wet compression molded tunnel.

BMW continues to work closely with its resin suppliers. “We have developed faster resins since the i3 and i8,” Ahlers notes, “and we also did all new testing, starting with coupon testing to feed the simulations and then moving up through components to qualify each material for each part.”

At this point, BMW Group Plant Dingolfing’s head of Press Shop and CFRP Production Peter Wolferseder takes over the tour. As he leads the way into the open production area, he explains that the CFRP Shop’s 100 employees cover three shifts, five days per week. Inside, a bank of 10 automated CNC milling machines supplied by EIMA Maschinenbau (Frickenhausen, Germany) flanks the left side with a line of presses opposite — five for wet compression molding and two for hybrid B-pillar pressing — all supplied by Dieffenbacher North America Inc. (Eppingen, Germany). Many of the tools in the presses, he says, are supplied by FRIMO Inc. (Lotte, Germany). “We have a good relationship with them, and we also build some tools in-house.”

Walking past the CNC milling cells, Wolferseder shows how a wet-compression-molded tunnel part is placed into the front of the machine while another is milled at the back, for maximum throughput and efficiency (Fig. 5). “No dust escapes,” he points outs. “It is a completely clean environment.”

Wet pressing of sills

The sills that run along the lower sides of the BIW are assembled from two CFRP parts, also wet compression molded. A sill manufacturing cell equipped with two Kuka Robotics Corp. (Augsburg, Germany) robotic arms applies epoxy resin simultaneously to two dry textile preforms. The non-crimp fabric (NCF) for the preforms is made at BMW’s joint venture plant SGL Automotive Carbon Fibers, 60 minutes away in Wackersdorf, which also supplies the i3 and i8 lines. The resin is mixed and injected via a dual-head system supplied by Krauss-Maffei Corporation (Munich, Germany), with an integrated volume flowmeter that records the quantity applied to each stack. The resin forms a pool in the center of the stacks, leaving about an inch or so around the edges. “If the resin goes to the edges, then the needle grippers we use to pick up the preforms would get covered in resin and no longer work,” explains Wolferseder (Figs. 6a and 6b). “The resin application is programmed to fully impregnate to the edges during the pressing.”

Why two robots instead of one? “Because both preforms should be the same,” Wolferseder responds, “with the resin sitting on them for the same amount of time. If you only had one robot, one preform would have resin sitting for some seconds more than the other. Also, the robots are not very costly, so it is no issue to have two.”

Designed with latency, so cure does not begin until the press cycle, the resin sits for some seconds, penetrating through the preforms vertically. The wet preforms are picked up and placed
in the press by the robotically actuated needle grippers. The press then applies pressure according to specified ramp, with the final 10 mm of “daylight” closed very slowly. “Our special recipe to produce these parts is to coordinate the temperature, pressure and resin curve,” says Wolferseder.

Two molded stacks are produced with one stroke (Fig. 6c). “We will cut these in half so that we end up with four parts from one cycle,” says Wolferseder. “We mostly use tools with four cavities to increase the overall output capacity of our machines.”

He points out that this is a completely unattended process and totally reliable. “There are two people at the end to take parts off the line and to do QA checks. If there is a defect, they can address this in the machines,” says Wolferseder. “Wet pressing is not unique,” he adds. “What is unique is this industrialization.”

Hybrid B-pillars

The prepreg used to reinforce the B pillars is delivered from Hexcel Austria (Neumarkt) using epoxy resin from an undisclosed supplier and carbon fiber from SGL Carbon SE (Wiesbaden). It arrives precut to shape and on trays, which are stacked onto trolleys and rolled into the workcell’s feed station. “The solid green layer on top is the epoxy adhesive which will bond the CFRP to the hot-formed steel B-pillar,” says Wolferseder, “but also provide isolation against galvanic corrosion.”

A robot picks up two of the adhesive-coated prepreg preforms and places them on a light table to enable an automated stack orientation check, which is completed in a few seconds by a Vision Machine Technic (Mannheim, Germany) system. The robot then picks up the preforms again and after returning to the workcell’s periphery swivels to the other side of the robot transit aisle and places the prewforms into one of several drawers in a convection oven. Here, the CFRP preforms and the steel B-pillars are preheated before pressing. The preforms are then transferred from the heating drawer to a forming station where they are placed onto and shaped by a set of pins that essentially form an articulated tool. After this is completed, the two shaped preforms are mated to two preheated steel B pillars and then fed into the press. A twin-cavity tool, supplied by Koller Formenbau (Dietfurt, Germany), molds a complete set of left and right B-pillars in one stroke. Wolferseder explains that the presses used here are the same as those employed in wet pressing, but the pre-and post-press equipment is completely different.

After a high-temp, high-pressure cycle, the two finished parts are removed and set on a shelf where they will cool at ambient temperature. “The cooling stage is needed in order for the parts to finish hardening,” says Wolferseder, “and also for the two workers at the end of the line to be able to handle them.” The robot receives a signal that the temperature of the parts is cool enough and then transfers them to the conveyor belt where the workers will pick them up, perform a visual inspection for quality and will also remove the peel ply/foil on top of the prepreg. “The CFRP allows us to use a thinner, more lightweight steel part,” says Wolferseder, “saving 2 kg while providing superior crash performance.”

Dingolfing Body Shop

A short drive from the CFRP Shop is the 40,000m² Body Shop, where CFRP parts and metal parts from the Press Shop are joined into modules, which then are assembled into the 7 Series BIW. CW’s tour here is led by Christoph Roth, head of production for the BMW 7 Series Body-in-White. Scanning the floor from an overhead viewing bay, the high degree of automation is obvious — 460 robotic arms are used in the shop’s 7 Series section alone, overseen by 130 technicians per shift.

Roth explains that CFRP parts come into this building through an exterior washing area where dust from machining is removed. “All of the parts do this except for the B-pillars because they are not machined and they are also not bonded during BIW production, only welded,” Roth explains. “This washing and then drying is necessary because all of these parts will be bonded, so the surfaces must be very clean.” The CFRP parts are fed into the Body Shop on a just-in-time (JIT) basis, directed from the overall production control system. After drying, the parts are sent to one of the 20 automated production cells that join the CFRP parts to metal. These cells produce parts for all 7 Series derivatives, including left and right hand drives and extra-length version.

“Figuring out how to join all of these parts and the production cells needed was the challenge,” says Roth. “Every joining method already existed somewhere in the automotive industry, but the challenge was how to bring it all together with these new materials and make it all work for our production cycles.” The roof frames and lower sill reinforcements are glued and riveted, but the rivets are used only to hold the glued surfaces in contact until the epoxy adhesive cures. “We decide on what fasteners to use depending on where the part is in the car, the material and also the access,” he explains. “If you can only access one side, then you use flow-drill-screws, for which we have also developed very innovative new technology.” The latter require no pilot hole, feature an undercut beneath the heads and very fast installation, which heats up the surrounding material and, as a result, “welds” the fasteners in to a degree. Roth continues, “We use 150 flow-drill-screws per each 7 Series BIW. If the machine can gain access to top and bottom, then we can use rivets.”

Roth describes one area where fasteners have been eliminated: “The aluminum casted part that is glued to the CF SMC rear support replaces up to 30 separate parts but has now been integrated into a one-piece unit.” Walking past multiple rectangular, fenced-in production cells, each with two or three robotic arms moving parts through various preparation and joining operations, he points out a worker who is performing ultrasonic inspection on a completed subassembly. “Three parts per shift are pulled from each station and tested either nondestructively or with light force to ensure strength.”

Tunnel assembly cell

Trolleys with CFRP and metal parts are loaded into the auto- mated production cell. A Kuka robotic arm picks up a CFRP tunnel and rotates it beneath a mix, meter and dispense (MMD) nozzle for application of epoxy adhesive (Fig. 7). The part is then placed under a set of cameras for a quick QA check of adhesive placement vs. a reference. “There must be no interruptions in the length, and it also checks the width of the adhesive bead,” explains Roth. “It doesn’t worry about the thickness because we apply more adhesive than necessary and also use spacers, which maintain the distance between the parts for uniform bondline thickness.”

“We use roughly 150m of glue per 7 Series BIW,” says Roth. There are drums of adhesive from Sika AG (Baar, Switzerland) and also MMD machines at each production cell. “We have used SIKA and bonding for metal parts for years,” says Roth, “but the adhesive we use for the CFRP stations is a specialty adhesive for CFRP-to-sheet-metal bonding.”

The tunnel is then mated to the steel components of this subassembly. Rivets are applied to affix the CFRP and steel pieces together until the epoxy hardens five hours later, when the BIW goes into the paint oven. The tunnel production cell produces 17 units per hour.

When asked about issues encountered while developing the various press cells, Roth responds, “The challenge was how to qualify personnel to repair and maintain these new machines for joining multiple materials. So, we pulled our best maintenance personnel and placed them within the process development group so that they would understand the technology behind these machines and processes.” These personnel then became specialists for the new joining equipment. “It is key that they were involved from the beginning,” Roth adds.

Building the Carbon Core

Other cells that join CFRP and metal parts include those for sills, B- and C-pillars and roof rail assemblies. Most of the completed subassemblies that contain CFRP are used to form the BIW’s mid-section. The C pillar reinforcement and upper trunk cover are on the rear section (Fig. 8). The front section is all metal.

Once a subassembly is completed, it is loaded by elevator onto an overhead conveyor that transports it to the BIW assembly line. Assembly of the BIW begins with key steel and aluminum chassis pieces joined and welded atop a moving sled. The BIW then progresses through subsequent stations where additional subassemblies are lowered, robotically placed, fastened and/or welded until the Carbon Core is complete (Fig. 9).

Final assembly line

Completed BIWs are painted before proceeding through Hall 52, which produces 5, 6 and 7 Series vehicles. An adjacent Hall 50 produces BMW 3,4 and 5 Series cars. A car rolls off the line every 83 seconds in Hall 52, and every 58 seconds in Hall 50. Each hall contains 350-400 stations on three levels: Pre-assembly modules are on the ground floor (level 0) and transported up to level 2, where vehicle assembly is completed and then back down to level 1 for the finishing line.

“All of our cars are built to order, so this presents a challenge,” notes CW’s guide for Hall 52, head of assembly at BMW Group Plant Dingolfing Robert Küssel. “There is no other auto manufacturing center that has this much complexity.” Stopping at one position in the line, an instrument panel is fed up from the ground floor through an elevator. This station’s technician walks over and attaches a robot to the completed IP module. He then guides it to a car moving slowly through the line where he places it inside, but the robot does the installation. The whole process is controlled and documented by the equipment. “Parts are sequenced in Logistics in what we call Lineside Supply,” says Küssel, “this builds in a lot of flexibility to our assembly lines. We can easily adapt to new parts and new models.” He notes the whole building is fed by 200 multi-car material supply train cars per hour.

On the finishing line, cars are tested again for functionality of each subsystem. Transported to the ground floor, they are driven through a short test track to check noise, vibration and harshness (NVH).

A certain number of cars per shift are selected for road testing on a longer test track adjacent to the assembly halls, and a subset of those go out on the highway next to the facility for a longer test. “It’s all about quality,” says Küssel. “Our customers expect a very high level of quality from us.”

CFRP-integrated industrial production

And that is the real story of this plant: Efficiency in manufacturing, yet quality in every detail, despite myriad individually specified components. Carbon parts may be made in their own shop, but they are prepped, joined and painted with all of the other BIW parts into a coherent, well-designed and high-performance platform. CFRP is just another specialty, another complexity, another functionality rolled into what BMW already does so well. It has become standard procedure, but only because the company recognized and addressed challenges early on, in areas as diverse as the carbon fiber supply chain, part processing, isolation from galvanic corrosion, quality control and technician training.

“We use CFRP not just here and there in a visual part to be flashy,” says Küssel, “but in a way that adds functionality and performance to the car.” Articles in the industry press suggest that BMW will extend CFRP use into new Motorrad motorcycle models and an all-electric i5 crossover SUV expected to be revealed next year and in production by 2019. Upon exiting Plant 2.4, and seeing several camouflaged, pre-production vehicles undergoing tests, CW’s question is: “which Dingolfing model will be next?”